Subscriber OnlyLetters

Population size matters in public spending comparisons

Institutions in France, Spain and Italy benefit from economies of scale not available in a small country such as Ireland

Letters to the Editor. Illustration: Paul Scott

Sir, – David McWilliams (“How can Ireland afford to be so generous to public sector workers?”, November 14th) argues Government spending per capita is more revealing than comparisons using spending as a percentage of national income.

This may be true, but the countries McWilliams lists who spend much less than us per capita, France, Spain and Italy, have populations 10 times the size of Ireland. Their public institutions benefit from economies of scale not available in a small country like ours.

The cost of running a State broadcaster, or other core State institution, spread over a population of 50 million is going to be lower than the per capita comparison in Ireland. On its own, this measurement doesn’t prove that the Irish institution is less productive.

Comparisons based on single blunt measurements might support a point but they never reveal the full truth. – Yours, etc,

KAY CHALMERS,

Douglas,

Cork.