Cameron rules out another Scottish independence vote

British PM reluctant to grant fiscal autonomy demanded by Nicola Sturgeon

SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon greets British Prime Minister David Cameron at Bute House, Charlotte Square, Edinburgh. Photograph:  EPA/Robert Perry
SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon greets British Prime Minister David Cameron at Bute House, Charlotte Square, Edinburgh. Photograph: EPA/Robert Perry

A second Scottish independence referendum is “not remotely on the cards”, British prime minister David Cameron has said.

But nationalist demands for greater powers to be devolved from London to Scotland will be considered.

Mr Cameron was speaking after meeting Scottish National Party leader Nicola Sturgeon in Edinburgh just over a week after the SNP won almost every seat in Scotland in the general election.

Scots rejected independence in a referendum last year by 55 to 45 per cent. Asked whether he would veto another such referendum, Mr Cameron told the BBC: “I don’t think it’s remotely on the cards.”

READ MORE

“I’m very clear: we had a referendum, it had a decisive outcome. The choice now is what sort of future for Scotland in the United Kingdom.”

Ms Sturgeon, whose party won 56 out of 59 Scottish seats, used the meeting to tell Mr Cameron she wanted him to go well beyond an existing deal to grant more powers to the devolved Scottish government.

Although Mr Cameron’s Conservatives performed strongly in England and won an overall UK-wide majority, they won just one seat in Scotland.

Mr Cameron had already agreed to further dismantle Britain’s highly centralised system of government and to give Scotland, which already enjoys a large degree of autonomy, new tax-raising powers.

EU choice

But Ms Sturgeon said she’d told Mr Cameron she wanted him to go well beyond a deal reached last year after a process known as the Smith Commission.

“I have said that we will put forward proposals for devolution further than the Smith Commission proposals,” she told Sky News after the meeting, saying Scotland wanted a greater say over business taxes, employment legislation, the minimum wage and welfare payments.

Mr Cameron said he would look at the proposals, but made no promises to agree to them. He said he was opposed to granting Scotland full fiscal autonomy, something the SNP is pushing for.

The SNP argues its victory last week shows Scottish voters have decisively rejected public spending cuts imposed by the Conservatives. Ms Sturgeon argues that any future settlement must give Scotland the power to pursue the less austere policies Scottish voters demand.

Scotland’s three-centuries-old union with England could depend on the fate of another: Mr Cameron has promised to renegotiate Britain’s relationship with the European Union and hold an in-or-out EU membership referendum by the end of 2017.

Ms Sturgeon has said that if England voted to leave the EU but Scotland voted to stay, it could trigger another referendum on Scottish independence.

The SNP is due to face Scottish voters once again in an election for the Scottish parliament next year. Some voters say Ms Sturgeon’s new mandate means she has no excuse if she fails to deliver on her promises.

Reuters