Ireland

Frontline gardaí cannot ‘stand back and tolerate abuse’ at migrant protests  

Commissioner said avoiding direct and immediate action helps keep the peace and foster integration

Garda engage local residents as they blockade the asylum seeker accommodation at the Magowna House hotel in Inch, Co Clare, last week. Photograph: Niall Carson/PA Wire

Vivienne Clarke
Tue May 23 2023 - 09:07

A time will come when gardaí cannot tolerate the level of abuse they face during confrontations, the president of the Garda Representative Association said on Monday after the Garda Commissioner defended Garda Siochána tactics in dealing with protests.

Commissioner Drew Harris on Monday said gardaí would not “fall into the trap” of heavy-handed tactics in dealing with far-right protesters who have a “playbook” that desires confrontation.

The policing chief was responding to calls to clear the roadblock on the approach to International Protection applicant accommodation in Inch, Co Clare.

He said any direct and immediate policing action could create “a well of bad feeling” towards foreign nationals being moved into those areas. Instead, the Garda had to take a strategic and long-term approach, which kept the peace and fostered integration.

READ MORE

Brendan O’Connor said that while he agreed with Mr Harris there comes a point where gardaí could not “stand back and tolerate the levels of abuse that’s been thrown at them and cameras pointed in their faces. So that’s kind of the element that we would be concerned with.”

“The guards have a long tradition of finding the right point in relation to the use of force”, the representative of the rank and file told Newstalk Breakfast.

Mr O’Connor also welcomed proposals before Cabinet for higher sentences for attacks on gardaí and emergency service workers. The proposals would see the maximum sentence expanded, rather than an imposition of a minimum sentence.

“We welcome any acknowledgment or any move towards trying to create some disincentives against assaults on our members,” Mr O’Connor said.

“We would caution that we don’t believe it’s enough. We have always called for a mandatory custodial sentence for attacks and we have seen in relation to all legislation and all statutes available that the maximum sentence is something that’s very, very rarely applied in any case. So we’ll wait to see if it has any impact. And certainly it’s welcomed that the Government acknowledges the problem, but it’s not what we would have asked for.

“It’s whether it’s applied or not, we’ll have to wait and see. But our experience in relation to any legislation and punishment is that maximum sentence is not a feature of most sentencing. So we would see the logic, I’m told by the Minister that the fact that the standards applied is usually a proportion of the maximum, and we should see that reflected in sentences over time. We’re not sure.”

[ Far right ‘not growing’, says Garda Commissioner, as number of protests halves ]

[ Garda on course to lose 500 members via resignations and retirements by year-end ]

When asked his opinion on new guidelines for gardaí involved in high speed chases, Mr O’Connor said the current guidelines were not fit for purpose. “What we have is a protocol, a system brought into place which is designed to manage pursuits, but really the foundations aren’t there to underpin the policy document because we don’t have trained drivers, we don’t have the systems in place.

“A lot of what we have is lifted from the UK or multiple jurisdictions where we have live links from technology and cameras and cars, where we have properly trained drivers, where we have quite high powered police vehicles. So the model really isn’t applicable to the standard of driving available.

“Guards are accountable for their decision making and we’re also accountable in the eyes of the law. Traffic pursuits are one of the highest risk activities any police officer can become involved in so certainly the stakes are very high. Guards have to be very acutely aware of their decision making and their actions”.

Mr O’Connor said there needed to be a better balance between the standards to which gardaí were being held and the obligation to bring offenders to account.

LATEST STORIES