Taoiseach Micheál Martin recently announced a proposal to establish a new government body to research and explore alternative constitutional futures for the island of Ireland. While most people may not link this announcement with climate justice, fossil fuel phase-out or growing opposition to data centres, the process of envisioning new constitutional futures for Ireland creates a unique opportunity to reimagine our shared island with a state designed to protect its people against the incoming climate tsunami while minimising our contribution to it.
Climate justice is essential in considering alternative constitutional futures because it recognises that those most vulnerable to the climate crisis have contributed the least, and new structures are needed to rein in powerful corporate actors who are blocking transformative climate action to support our collective futures. Climate justice acknowledges that the climate crisis is not a problem that can be fixed with technological solutions. Rather, it is a devastating symptom of extractive systems that concentrate wealth and power among large corporate interests. Climate justice strives to rectify these injustices by constraining corporate power and redistributing economic and political power to people and communities.
Currently, neither of the two jurisdictions on the island is designed, structured or governed to respond to the intensifying climate and ecological threats that the people of Ireland are facing.
In both the North and the South, ecological health is rapidly deteriorating as public policy reinforces fossil fuel dependency, while governance structures that disregard ecological health are failing to protect waterways, land and biodiversity. The inability of the current governance systems to prevent the devastating toxic pollution in the island’s largest lake, Lough Neagh, the “dying” lake that provides 40 per cent of drinking water in the North, demonstrates fundamental governance failures.
READ MORE
In both jurisdictions, household energy costs are soaring – they are among the highest in Europe – with hundreds of thousands of households unable to pay their bills. In both jurisdictions the needs of extractive and exploitative multinational companies – including the tech industry, the agri-food industry and mining – are being prioritised over the needs of households, communities, local businesses and local food farmers.
The proliferation of fossil-fuelled data centres to power AI is devouring huge amounts of energy, resulting in increased costs for households and adding strain on the grid and water systems.
Support for cities, towns and rural communities to prepare for extreme heat, flooding, and sea-level rise is dangerously inadequate, and failure to meet climate goals is evident North and South. A lack of transparency and scant accountability is breeding widespread mistrust in politics and intensifying political polarisation.
Given the inability of Ireland’s current governance systems to address these worsening intersecting crises and reduce environmental harm, envisioning new constitutional futures is a critically important opportunity for the people of this island. In the process ahead, climate justice provides a transformative framework that offers hope and inspiration and also moves the public debate beyond the simplistic yes-no framing that has dominated public discourse on the constitutional question.
During this time of intensifying climate destruction, instead of asking whether there should be a new constitution, the most important question is how can the constitutional futures process redefine shared values, reprioritise fundamental rights and safeguard collective wellbeing on the island.
Climate justice principles are helpful because they broaden the agenda and link public health and wellbeing with ecological health. A climate justice framework opens up possibilities for a transformative vision of alternative economic systems that prioritise human rights, regeneration instead of extraction, and delivering quality housing, food, healthcare, education and an equitable, healthy, stable environment for all.
Ireland’s history and geography means that we are uniquely positioned to reimagine our future and restructure governance for the public good.
Now is a time to be bold and courageous in our political imaginations. As Trinity professor and author Michael Cronin argues in his book Ireland: Why it Matters to be an Island, we need to shift our mindset away from disputes over land towards recognising that our shared future as islanders is existentially threatened by rising seas and climate destruction. Given the accelerating climate disruptions and deepening vulnerabilities, we cannot afford to limit our ambition to what is conventionally deemed “politically achievable”.
As the Taoiseach’s initiative invests public resources to explore alternative constitutional futures, climate justice needs to be at the core.
Jennie C Stephens is professor of climate justice at Maynooth University and co-convener of the Climate Justice Universities Union












