Closing stages reached in trial of Galway teenage rape accused

The now 16-year-old accused has pleaded not guilty to three charges of oral rape and one of rape

21/04/2017
STOCK: The Courts of Criminal Justice on Parkgate St. Dublin
Photograph: Dave Meehan/The Irish Times
The Criminal Courts of Justice Exterior view
CCJ
The incidents are alleged to have occurred in a Co Galway housing estate where both children were living with their families, the court heard. Photograph: Dave Meehan/ The Irish Times

Closing stages have been reached in the trial of a Co Galway teenage boy charged with the rape and sexual assault of a teenage girl he had been dating for a few weeks.

The now 16-year-old accused pleaded not guilty at the Central Criminal Court to three charges of sexual assault involving oral rape and one of rape of the then 13-year-old girl on dates between June and July 2023.

The incidents are alleged to have occurred in a Co Galway housing estate where both children were living with their families. The accused was 14 years old at the time.

The jury has heard closing speeches from the prosecution and defence counsel and has been charged by Mr Justice Patrick McGrath. They retired to consider their verdict on Friday afternoon and deliberated for approximately 40 minutes before being sent home for the weekend.

During her evidence, the girl said she told several friends before telling her mother what had happened.

Before the evidence in the case concluded, an investigating garda told the jury that investigators contacted the parents of these children and some of them did not agree to facilitate interviews.

The garda also confirmed that the girl’s mother gave her a screenshot of a Snapchat message from the girl, but other Snapchat messages could not be retrieved.

During cross-examination, the garda agreed with John Berry SC, defending, that several attempts were made to confirm the dates on which these incidents allegedly occurred. She noted the girl said, “I think” and was unsure in relation to exact dates.

A local garda outlined in evidence how he and a colleague met the girl to take the complaint in the presence of her mother. He said this was a preliminary meeting, and not the formal process of taking the girl’s complaint.

Under cross-examination, this garda agreed with Mr Berry that the official garda report of this meeting contained a range of dates between early and late June 2023, when the offences allegedly occurred. He confirmed that this was information given by the girl, and that any other information would have been in the report.

Mr Berry noted that the specialist forensic examiner outlined in her evidence a different and shorter range of dates in late June. The witness said he didn’t know where these dates came from.

Earlier in the trial, the forensic examiner told the jury that it had taken some time to confirm dates with the girl, who was “tearful” and finding it difficult to talk about the alleged incidents.

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Sign up for push alerts to get the best breaking news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone

  • Listen to In The News podcast daily for a deep dive on the stories that matter