India-Pakistan talks fail to tackle Kashmir

Kashmir: Foreign Ministers of India and Pakistan ended a first round of talks looking for ways to advance a faltering peace …

Kashmir: Foreign Ministers of India and Pakistan ended a first round of talks looking for ways to advance a faltering peace process, amid signs of discord over the decades-old dispute in Kashmir.

Pakistani foreign minister Khursheed Mehmood Kasuri and his Indian counterpart, Natwar Singh, shook hands and voiced commitment to friendly relations before sitting down for talks followed by delegation-level discussions.

"The meetings were held in a friendly, cordial and affable and constructive atmosphere," Indian foreign ministry spokesman Navtej Sarna said.

"There is a determination to take this forward and make progress in whatever fields we can." The talks are due to end today.

READ MORE

Analysts said the two sides, which embarked on the peace process nine months ago, might announce some agreements on a raft of confidence-building proposals, including transport links and people-to-people contacts.

But the nuclear rivals remained far apart on the central dispute of Kashmir and the tensions were apparent.

Mr Sarna said New Delhi raised its concerns over renewed guerrilla incursions into Indian Kashmir from Pakistan, a charge which Islamabad immediately rejected.

India has also insisted that talks must cover all outstanding issues and not be held hostage to Kashmir. Pakistan has sought to focus attention on the disputed Himalayan region and involve Kashmiris in the peace process, drawing an angry Indian response.

Mr Kasuri, who said he would try to persuade New Delhi to involve Kashmiris in the dialogue, met top Kashmiri separatist leaders, including Syed Ali Shah Geelani, head of a pro-Pakistan group, and chief cleric Mirwaiz Umar Farooq.

"Any talks that do not include the Kashmiri people will not be fruitful," Mr Farooq said later.

But India, which considers the former state of Kashmir to be an integral part of its country, bristles against any involvement of a third party in what it says is a bilateral dispute with Pakistan.

"There is considerable disappointment here today at the statement made by the Pakistan foreign minister about India-Pakistan relations," Mr Sarna said.

"This is not in consonance with the spirit in which we have conducted the composite dialogue so far. It also violates Pakistan's own call for a rhetoric restraint regime."

In reiterating Pakistan's long-held views on Kashmir, Mr Kasuri had implicitly blamed Indian intransigence for the impasse.

"All along, the question before us has been very simple. We should give the Kashmiris the choice to determine their own future. This choice should have been given them in August 1947. But, 57 years later, we are still at the starting line."

Mr Kasuri tried to calm the waters yesterday. "We are not uni-focal," he told reporters. "We will have to talk on all issues."

The neighbours, who went to the brink of war in 2002, embarked on a peace process last January with a new sense of purpose. But some of that hope has dissipated in recent months, especially after the Congress party won back power in May, replacing the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party.- (Reuters)