Expressions of Christmas goodwill were quickly forgotten when Government and Opposition members crossed swords over Dr Patrick Leahy, who died on Thursday.
Mr Joe O'Toole (Ind) asked the House to note the passing of the general practitioner who, he said, had symbolised democracy in its purest form and who had been a catalyst to extraordinary debate and emotion. "He was someone who made us face our demons and confront our taboos. I think he made a huge contribution to Irish life," he said.
Mr David Norris (Ind) described Dr Leahy as a great, courageous and noble spirit. Mr Michael Finneran (FF) expressed sympathy with Dr Leahy's family but said he was surprised at the statements that had been made about him. He understood that Dr Leahy "supported the area of euthanasia and abortion". He was taken aback that Mr O'Toole, the leader of a teachers' organisation, should pay tribute to someone who held such views.
Angry exchanges followed, and Mr Norris called on Mr Finneran to sit down and shut up. Ms Avril Doyle (FG) said Mr Finneran's comments were inappropriate.
"The man is not yet cold," she said.
The Cathaoirleach, Mr Brian Mullooly, said Mr Finneran was totally out of order. "That is one of the reasons why we don't have votes of sympathy in the House," he said.
Mr O'Toole said there was a tradition in the Upper House that issues were not brought up in relation to deceased people in a way that created controversy. He had made it clear that he had not been referring to the issues raised by Dr Leahy.
Mr Finneran accused him of raising contentious matters.