The title on the glittery gold graph reads: “I wanna be destroyed, fictionally.” Pink bars stretch up the page, evaluating the “level of sad” for each book listed. Toni Morrison’s Beloved ranks the highest.
The colourful recommendation chart, one of many that have rippled through the Twitter and Instagram feeds of book lovers, came from a small Madison bookstore in Wisconsin, in the US, called A Room of One’s Own.
Fawzy Taylor, the social media and marketing manager of the store, which is described as queer, feminist and trans-owned, designed the graphics and posted them on the store’s accounts. The flowcharts bring to mind the candy-coloured quizzes of early 2000s teen magazines. But instead of questions like, “who’s your Twilight soul mate?” these charts offer a choose-your-own-adventure approach to finding your new favourite book.
They inspired a fellow bookseller, 24-year-old Mariah Charles of Austin, Texas to make a set of book charts of her own. The charts seem to speak the internet’s language, one that meets people where they are by acknowledging that literature can be overwhelming, and people often don’t know where to start.
Megan Nolan: A conversation with a man in his late 30s made clear the realities of this new era in my dating life
Changing career midlife: ‘At 45 I thought I was finished... But it didn’t even occur to me that I could do anything else’
Restaurant of the year, best value and Michelin predictions: Our reviewer’s top picks of 2024
Women are far more likely to re-gift unwanted presents than men
That desire – to provide a guide for the overwhelmed reader – is what inspired 32-year-old Taylor to make the first chart. A James Baldwin superfan, Taylor runs an Instagram account called the James Baldwin Archive, which celebrates the author’s work. For Baldwin’s birthday August 2nd, Taylor made a display at the bookstore, but found that customers hadn’t touched it a few days later.
“So I just assumed that people were overwhelmed,” Taylor says. “I’m easily overwhelmed, especially with things I think I should already know about.”
The first flowchart was born. Titled “Never read Baldwin before?” the chart gives readers various options: “I wanna be happy” tells the reader to “Go read a different author”. The “It is hard for me to focus” option leads to The Last Interview. The chart received over 37,000 likes on Twitter, reaching far beyond the bookstore’s own following.
“A lot of our work at the bookstore is to have these conversations that the flowcharts really mimic,” Taylor says.
Book recommendation flowcharts aren’t a new phenomenon, says Naomi S Baron, an emerita professor of linguistics at American University and the author of How We Read Now. But if these charts are uniquely resonating with people now, she hypothesises that it’s because they fulfil a need for the specialised book recommendations that readers used to get at independent bookstores.
“If these charts are well done, they can serve a function that’s all too rarely available now,” Baron says. “Because there are so few independent bookstores [and], depending on how immunocompromised you are, going on two and 1/2 or more years, you haven’t been going to those bookstores and you had to rely on Amazon’s ‘you might also like’.”
“I think it’s important, if you want to talk about what’s going on over the last couple of years, we need comfort food. And these are friendly and welcoming.”
Lynn Lobash, the associate director of reader services at the New York Public Library, says that these flowcharts capture the kind of reading recommendation conversations that she and her colleagues have every day. The charts “give everyday language to something that can be really hard to talk about,” Lobash said.
Compared to more traditional reading lists, Lobash says the flowcharts are “more interactive” and honour the way that readers’ tastes, feelings and moods change. “We don’t want to read the same book over and over again,” she says. “When you love something, you want to repeat that feeling of love for it.”
But will the charts lead people to actually read or even just buy the books? Lobash is hopeful. “I think that these flowcharts will definitely lead to reading,” she says. “People love a book recommendation.”
Taylor is happy the charts seems to have reignited some joy and excitement in reading, and given readers an entry point into unfamiliar texts. “I just want reading to be fun for people,” Taylor says. “I do not care what they read. I just want them to read joyfully.” Of course, a little business for the bookstore wouldn’t hurt, either. – This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
