A High Court judge has directed an inquiry into the legality of law student Simeon Burke’s ongoing detention in a Dublin prison.
In a ruling on Wednesday evening, Mr Justice Anthony Barr said that sufficient evidence had been raised regarding the 24-year-old Co Mayo man’s detention at Cloverhill Prison so as to merit the court directing an inquiry under Article 40.4 of the Constitution.
Mr Justice Barr gave his decision following an ex-parte application brought on Wednesday afternoon by Mr Burke’s sister, Ammi Burke, on behalf of her brother, who is currently detained at the prison on foot of an alleged breach of the peace following an incident at the Court of Appeal last month.
The judge said that Mr Burke has raised issues concerning the lawfulness of both his arrest and treatment at the hand of the Garda, and ongoing detention. He also made complaints about the District Court’s handling of his case.
Four years, five courts, 29 judges... the Burkes of Castlebar and their never-ending legal battles
Fintan O’Toole: Enoch Burke is no freak. His extreme logic was part of Irish education for years
The Burkes of Castlebar: Who are the high-achieving family from Co Mayo?
Lawyer Simeon Burke cannot get a master. Is this his own fault or due to an arcane system?
He further claims that the breach of his constitutional rights is so egregious that the District Court lacks the jurisdiction to hear the case against him.
While there were clearly “two sides to the story”, the judge said that an inquiry into Mr Burke’s imprisonment, where both sides can make submissions on the legality of the detention, was merited.
The inquiry will take place before the duty judge at the Four Courts during Thursday’s vacation sitting of the court.
As part of his inquiry, Mr Burke seeks an order from the court directing his immediate release from Cloverhill.
Mr Justice Barr’s decision comes after two other High Court judges, Mr Justice Mark Heslin and Ms Justice Melanie Greally, ruled against directing inquiries into Simeon Burke’s detention.
In her submissions to Mr Justice Barr on Wednesday, Ammi Burke strongly criticised the other judges’ refusal to entertain the applications, and rejected Ms Justice Greally’s contention that she was “forum shopping”.
She said that it was a matter of “basic law” that a third party can seek an Article 40 inquiry on a prisoner’s behalf. She also argued that multiple applications for such an inquiry can be made before the courts in respect of the same person.
In his ruling, Mr Justice Barr said he was not making any comments in relation to any decisions made by other judges of the High Court.
However, he was satisfied that Ammi Burke did have the legal standing to apply for an inquiry.
The judge said that the courts have always “erred on the side of caution” when it comes to applications under Article 40.4 regarding a person’s liberty, and the threshold for directing such inquiries was “low”.
He added that the facts that Simeon Burke’s trial on the public order charge is due to take place early next week, and he has refused to take up bail, were not matters that prohibit the courts from directing an inquiry.
Simeon Burke, who the High Court heard will represent himself in the inquiry, has been remanded in custody since his arrest over a month ago with consent to bail, which he has declined to take up.
The accused, a younger brother of secondary school teacher Enoch Burke, has pleaded not guilty to a breach of the peace offence in connection with outbursts in the Court of Appeal on March 7th last.
Simeon Burke, who is a student barrister-at-law at the Kings Inns, has refused to sign a bail bond with a condition to stay away from the Four Courts, where his brother has been involved in a legal dispute with Wilson’s Hospital School in Co Westmeath.
Simeon Burke is charged with a breach of the peace, under the Public Order Act, for engaging in threatening, insulting and abusive words and behaviour at the Court of Appeal.
The offence carries a possible three-month custodial sentence.
Simeon Burke, with an address at Cloonsunna, Castlebar, Co Mayo, denies the charges and the contested hearing is due to take place before the District Court on April 17th.