Stocktake: Foundation of the market is ‘fragile’

Breadth was also weak in 2018, resulting in a 20 per cent correction later that year

US stocks are near all-time highs but weak market breadth continues to concern.

Even as the cap-weighted S&P 500 hit fresh highs last Tuesday, an equal-weighted version of the index fell almost 1 per cent (the equal-weight index weighs all 500 stocks in the index equally, whereas the cap-weighted version is dominated by the most valuable companies, like Apple and Microsoft).

Although the S&P 500 has hit multiple new highs over the last two months, its equal-weight counterpart has gone nowhere over the same period, notes Bespoke Investment.

Weak breadth is "potentially serious", says CFRA Research's Sam Stovall, as mega-cap strength is "masking growing internal weakness".

READ MORE

The same point is stressed by Morgan Stanley’s Mike Wilson, who says we’ve “never witnessed breadth this weak with major indices at all-time highs”. Markets have taken on a “much more defensive posture” under the surface, which Wilson characterises as a “rolling correction” with the most speculative assets tumbling from their highs.

The current environment reminds Wilson of 2018, when breadth was also weak and which eventually resulted in a 20 per cent correction in December.

“The foundation of the market is fragile,” says Wilson. “It needs to strengthen or else the major averages are vulnerable.”