Turkey-Syria earthquake: Death toll passes 20,000 as Erdogan admits response problems

Hopes of finding survivors fade amid freezing temperatures more than three days since the quake hit

Cold, hunger and despair gripped hundreds of thousands of people left homeless after the earthquakes that struck Turkey and Syria three days ago, as the death toll passed 20,000 on Thursday.

The rescue of a two-year-old boy after 79 hours trapped in the rubble of a collapsed building in Hatay, Turkey, and several other people, raised spirits among weary search crews. But hopes were fading that many more would be found alive in the ruins of towns and cities.

The death toll across both countries has now surpassed the more than 17,000 killed in 1999 when a similarly powerful quake hit northwest Turkey.

A Turkish official said the disaster posed “very serious difficulties” for the holding of an election scheduled for May 14th in which president Recep Tayyip Erdogan has been expected to face the toughest challenge in his two decades in power.


With anger simmering over the slow delivery of aid and delays in getting the rescue effort under way, it is bound to play into the voting should the election still go ahead.

Meanwhile, the first United Nations convoy carrying aid to stricken Syrians crossed over the border from Turkey, three days after the quake struck.

In Syria’s Idlib province, Munira Mohammad, a mother of four who had fled Aleppo after the earthquake, said: “It is all children here, and we need heating and supplies, last night we couldn’t sleep because it was so cold. It is very bad.”

Hundreds of thousands of people across both countries have been left homeless in the middle of winter. Many have camped out in makeshift shelters in supermarket car parks, mosques, roadsides or amid the ruins, often desperate for food, water and heat.

At a gas station near the Turkish town of Kemalpasa, people picked through cardboard boxes of donated clothes. In the port city of Iskenderun, Reuters journalists saw people huddled around campfires on roadsides and in wrecked garages and warehouses.

Authorities say some 6,500 buildings in Turkey collapsed and countless more were damaged.

The confirmed death toll in Turkey has risen to 17,134, says the government’s Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency. In Syria, already devastated by nearly 12 years of civil war, 1,347 people have died in government-held areas, according to state media, while aid service the White Helmets says 1,930 have died in the rebel-held northwest, bringing the overall total deaths to 20,411.

In Maras in Turkey, people camped inside a bank, taping a sheet in the window for privacy. Others had set up on the grass median of a main road, heating instant soup on fires and wrapping themselves in blankets.

In Antakya, few petrol stations had fuel and kilometres-long queues stretched from those that did.

In the devastated Syrian town of Jandaris, Ibrahim Khalil Menkaween walked in the rubble-strewn streets clutching a white body bag. He said he had lost seven members of his family including his wife and two of his brothers.

“I’m holding this bag for when they bring out my brother, and my brother’s young son, and both of their wives, so we can pack them in bags,” he said. “The situation is very bad. And there is no aid.”

Turkish officials say some 13.5 million people were affected in an area spanning roughly 450km from Adana in the west to Diyarbakir in the east. In Syria, people were killed as far south as Hama, 250km from the epicentre.

There were still some signs of hope.

A two-year-old boy was picked out of the rubble by a Romanian and Polish rescue team in Hatay 79 hours after the quake, video released by Turkey’s Humanitarian Relief Foundation (IHH) on Thursday showed.

The boy, wearing a blue, white and black striped sweater, cried as he was gently lifted from the hole where he had been trapped. He was carried away on a blanket. No other details were immediately available.

Another video from IHH showed a helmeted and dust-streaked rescuer weeping with emotion after successfully freeing a little girl from the rubble of a collapsed building in Kahramanmaras.

Turkish footage late on Wednesday showed a few more survivors being rescued, including Abdulalim Muaini, who was pulled from his collapsed home in Hatay, where he had remained since Monday next to his dead wife.

Many in Turkey have complained of a lack of equipment, expertise and support to rescue those trapped – sometimes even as they could hear cries for help.

Goal, the Irish aid agency, announced that it lost 26 of its relief workers in the earthquake. The charity has had 1,200 aid workers on the ground in Syria and Turkey since 2016 dealing with refugees from the civil war in Syria. All of those who died were either Turkish or Syrian.

Goal chief executive Siobhan Walsh said: “To say it has been a profoundly difficult week for the Goal Teams in Türkiye and Syria cannot be overstated. Because of the sheer geography of destruction, and Goal’s long-term presence in the communities so severely impacted, the scale of loss is far beyond anything we could have ever imagined.”

The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Tánaiste Micheál Martin expressed his condolences to Goal on the loss of so many aid workers. “The Goal staff members who lost their lives were carrying out vital humanitarian work to support the people of north-west Syria, who have suffered unimaginably over recent years,” he said.

Meanwhile, After facing criticism over the initial response, Mr Erdogan said on a visit to the area on Wednesday that operations were now working normally and promised no one would be left homeless.

Nevertheless, the disaster will pose an additional challenge to the long-ruling president in the election.

One official told Reuters it was too early to make any decision on elections, noting that a three-month state of emergency had been announced and that some 15 per cent of Turkey’s population lived in the affected area.

“We will look at developments but at the moment there are very serious difficulties in holding an election on May 14th,” he said.

In Syria, relief efforts are complicated by a conflict that has partitioned the country and wrecked its infrastructure.

The UN aid convoy entered Syria at the Bab Al Hawa crossing – a lifeline for accessing opposition-controlled areas where some four million people, many displaced by the war, were already relying on humanitarian aid.

The UN envoy to Syria, Geir Pedersen, said in Geneva “absolutely everything” was needed in terms of aid. Roads leading to the border crossing had been destroyed, causing delays, he said.

Syrian civil defence said at least 1,930 people were killed in opposition-held northwest Syria, and the government has reported 1,347 deaths.

El-Mostafa Benlamlih, the senior UN aid official in Syria, said 10.9 million people had been affected.

Syria’s ambassador to the United Nations on Wednesday admitted the government lacked capability and equipment, but blamed the war and western sanctions.

Syria’s president, Bashar al-Assad, has chaired emergency meetings on the earthquake but has not addressed the nation in a speech or news conference. – Reuters