Leinster Branch await Pembroke opinion on decision to play Lewis

HOCKEY:THE LEINSTER Branch is waiting to hear back from Pembroke following their recent controversial decision to play Irish senior international Tim Lewis against YMCA and Corinthians. Lewis, who had been playing in Europe with Crefelder THC, was released for the German club's winter break at the end of October and came back to Ireland. Crefelder do not resume playing until April 2011.

On his return Pembroke selected Lewis and he played in two matches prompting queries to the branch from both clubs.

It appears to be the Leinster Branch’s opinion that Pembroke have broken rules but they have given the Ballsbridge club time to explain their decision. The fact this weekend’s Irish Hockey League fixtures have been postponed because of the freezing weather probably gives some breathing space. The branch only heard Lewis had played after he was involved in Pembroke’s 1-1 draw with YMCA.

Essentially the branch has a problem with Lewis playing in the Leinster League because it is a qualifying tournament for the Irish Hockey League, which in turn is a qualifying event for the European Hockey League. Players are not permitted to play in the qualifying stages of the same competition for two different clubs.

But if the position of Lewis was allowed to stand and Pembroke were not deducted the points, nothing would prevent a club like Corinthians or Glenanne from flying in a player such as Belgium-based Stephen Butler for selective matches on a Saturday and having him back for Sunday league or cup fare in Europe.

The Leinster Branch has pointed out that Lewis and Pembroke did furnish them with a letter from Crefelder, in German, releasing him to play and if he returned to Germany when the outdoor competition resumes in April, they would have to get a new licence for him to play with them. “The main thing here is that it has to be controlled,” said a Leinster official. “It appears Pembroke have broken a rule and all we are saying to the club is give us your opinion on the matter.”