Ranked: The 15 greatest Irish moments at the Oscars

There has been plenty of under-celebrated domestic Irish talent at the Oscars. Tomm Moore, co-founder of Cartoon Saloon, has been nominated three times in best feature animation. Geraldine Fitzgerald and Dan O’Herlihy were among the acting nominees. Louis Marcus, the great documentarian, was nominated as long ago as 1973.

So apologies to all those who haven’t made this somewhat arbitrary list.

15. Michèle Burke wins best makeup for Quest for Fire (1983)

There was still much golden age royalty around when Kildare’s Michèle Burke shared the best makeup and hairstyling Oscar for Jean-Jacques Annaud’s prehistoric drama. Sadly, Burke could not be there to get the award from Jane Russell and Cornel Wilde. She later explained that, when she picked it up from the post office, she got the man at the desk to present it to her. “Everyone in the post office crowded around and applauded,” she said. “I thought: this is perfect.”

14. Josie McAvin wins best art direction for Out of Africa (1986)

McAvin should be as much an Irish legend as Richard Harris or Barry Fitzgerald. Born in 1919, the Dubliner was already a veteran by the time she picked up her Oscar in person from – how gloriously 1986! – Rebecca De Mornay and Michael J Fox. She had been nominated twice before, for The Spy Who Came in from the Cold in 1965 and Tom Jones in 1963, and appeared visibly moved at the podium. Her Oscar is on display in the foyer of the Irish Film Institute in Dublin.

Cillian Murphy: ‘Moving home from London was the best thing we did’

---

Kerry Condon: ‘Sometimes people look at me but they can’t place me. And that’s what I want to be – an actor’

---

‘When my grandad arrived he was illiterate, and now his grandson is earning this country an Oscar nomination’

---

Percival Everett: ‘What’s amazing to me is this denial that this history belongs to all of us’

---

13. Peter O’Toole wins the honorary Oscar in 2003

We have never quite settled the question of whether the great man was born in Leeds or Connemara, but he always called himself Irish. So who are we to disagree? O’Toole shared the bittersweet record for most acting nominations without a win – he and Glenn Close scored eight – and was initially reluctant to accept the honorary Oscar (though several recipients, including Ennio Morricone and Paul Newman, have subsequently gone to win a competitive prize). “Always the bridesmaid, never the bride, my foot!” he declared.

[ The 25 greatest films to lose out on best picture Oscar, ranked ]

12. Benjamin Cleary wins best short in 2016 (and the other shorts winners)

Come the evening of that famous Irish Oscars, there was only one actual domestic winner at the podium – though Brie Larson won best actress for Lenny Abrahamson’s Room. This writer was there to see Cleary, nominated for the delightful short Stutterer, stagger into the press room as if emerging from a thunder storm. Kudos also to Martin McDonagh, who won for Six Shooter in 2004 and Oorlagh and Terry George, who took the same prize for The Shore in 2011, and Tom Berkeley and Ross White’s An Irish Goodbye in 2023 (about which more below).

11. Richard Baneham scores a second Oscar in 2023

Among the more under-sung achievers in Irish creative life. Baneham, raised in Tallaght, received his second visual effects Oscar for his work on James Cameron’s Avatar: The Way of Water. “Go raibh maith agat,” he said from the podium. “To James Cameron, whose thumbprint is on every frame of this movie.” Baneham is among the most respected talents in that high-powered world. “I know you’re from Ireland,” Jon Landau, producer of Avatar, said to me in 2022. “I am going to give a shout-out to Richie Baneham . . . He’s phenomenal.”

10. Kenneth Branagh wins best screenplay in 2022

There was an awful lot going on at that ceremony. That was the year Will Smith stepped forwards and clobbered a dismayed Chris Rock. A large Irish presence from Branagh’s Belfast was there to see it: Judi Dench, Ciarán Hinds, Branagh himself. As things worked out the only win was for Branagh’s screenplay. “This story is the search for joy and hope in the face of violence and loss,” he said at the podium. By this stage he had already broken a record. Nobody else has, over a career, matched his nominations in seven different categories.

9. Neil Jordan wins best original screenplay for The Crying Game, 1992

Jordan’s twisty IRA drama was the very definition of a slow-burner. The film opened quietly and, ruthlessly promoted by Harvey Weinstein, gradually became a word-of-mouth hit. Jordan was typically befuddled at the podium. “I didn’t know these nominations were coming up and I was in the bathroom,” he said. “I think the way the audiences have embraced this film tells me audiences can embrace any range of characters or points of view.” He did not thank the now-disgraced Weinstein.

8. Nomination morning 2016

One could argue that the greatest moment for Irish film at the Oscars to that point came on January 12th, 2016, when two Irish films, Room and Brooklyn, picked up seven nominations between them. Ben Cleary was also nominated in the best live action short film section. The Irish Film Board scored more nominations that year than giants Paramount and Universal Studios combined. “It is the most extraordinary, exciting moment in Irish film,” James Hickey, then Film Board CEO, said on the day.

7. The world sings happy birthday to James Martin in 2023

When Tom Berkeley and Ross White won their best live-action short Oscars for An Irish Goodbye, they brought out James Martin, the film’s star, to lap up the applause. It had not been much reported that Martin, who has Down syndrome, was celebrating his 31st birthday that evening. The greatest collection of famous people in any one room all joined in to serenade him. “It doesn’t matter if you have Down syndrome, as long as you’re doing what you do,” the Belfast man later told the BBC. “I do what I can to be funny.” He now has an MBE.

6. George Bernard Shaw wins best screenplay, 1939

First Irish Oscar winner. You will find the answer to two durable trivia questions in this list. When Shaw won for the film version of Pygmalion in 1939, he became the first person to take both an Oscar and a Nobel Prize. He held the record alone until Bob Dylan won the Nobel in 2016 (no, Al Gore did not actually win an Oscar). He apparently regarded any prize from base Hollywood as an insult, but this did not stop him from displaying the Oscar on his mantelpiece.

5. Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova win best original song for Falling Slowly, 2008

One of the most unlikely stories in Irish Oscar history. John Carney’s Once, a tale of a couple falling in love about the streets of Dublin, was made on a shoestring and initially released quietly before building up a committed following that propelled its stars all the way to the Academy Awards. Hansard and Irglova’s performance was memorable. So was the presentation. Jon Stewart brought Marketa back to the stage after her initial thanks were truncated. Still makes the head spin.

4. Barry Fitzgerald wins best supporting actor (1945)

Here’s the other top trivia question. Fitzgerald, nominated as best actor and best supporting actor for his twinkly priest in Going My Way, remains the only person shortlisted for two acting awards for the same film in the same year. He ultimately won best supporting actor and the academy changed the rules to stop such an anomaly ever occurring again. The performance still triggers blubbing to this day. First Irish person to win an acting Oscar.

3. An Cailín Ciúin and the nomination morning of 2023

If the nomination toll in 2016 was a surprise, the haul seven years later beggared belief. A full 14 nominations went the way of Irish talent and Irish projects. Martin McDonagh’s The Banshees of Inisherin picked up nine of those, but the most notable mention was that for Colm Bairéad’s An Cailín Ciúin in best international film. No Irish film had previously made even the shortlist issued before Christmas. “It’s read out alphabetically. So we were the last and that was nail-biting stuff,” Bairéad said of the film (listed as The Quiet Girl at the Oscars). The journey had begun over a year earlier at a Covid-riddled Berlin Film Festival.

2. Daniel Day-Lewis wins best actor for My Left Foot, 1990

Towards the close of an already memorable evening for domestic cinema, Day-Lewis won the first of his ultimately record-breaking three best actor trophies. He had, at this stage, not yet taken Irish citizenship, but he made sure to identify himself with his heritage in his amusing, hairy speech. “You have just provided me with the makings of one hell of a weekend in Dublin,” he said. He defeated Tom Cruise, Robin Williams, Morgan Freeman and Kenneth Branagh to the prize. Not bad for a young one. Beaten into second place here because earlier that same evening . . .

1. Brenda Fricker wins best supporting actress, 1990

One could reasonably argue that the Oscar success of My Left Foot in 1990 signalled the beginning of a cultural and social renaissance that would transform the nation over the succeeding decade. First award of the evening went to Fricker for her turn as the determined mother of writer and artist Christy Brown. “I’d like to thank Mrs Brown, his mother,” Fricker said from the podium. “Anyone who gives birth 22 times deserves one of these.”

• Listen to our Inside Politics Podcast for the latest analysis and chat
• Sign up for push alerts and have the best news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone
• Find The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date