Crime & Law

Ballyfermot ‘crying out’ for a clear plan to break cycle of bad news in community

Councillor says concrete steps are needed as locals plan solidarity visit to Garda station after attack

The scene on the Ballyfermot Road where two gardaí were hospitalised on Sunday night after being attacked. Photograph: Colin Keegan/Collins Dublin

Olivia Kelleher
Tue Nov 22 2022 - 09:52

Members of the local community in Ballyfermot in Dublin plan to visit their local Garda station today to show solidarity with two gardaí who required hospital treatment after they were assaulted when they responded to a public order incident on Sunday night.

Local Fianna Fáil councillor Dáithá de Róiste, who is a member of the Dublin city Joint Policing Committee, says there is widespread shock and condemnation in relation to the attack in the local community.

However, he told Morning Ireland on RTÉ Radio 1 that we need to move on from such expressions of horror to developing a targeted response to assist both gardaí and the community in the area.

“Dublin city Joint Policing Committee meets today. Everybody condemns these actions but we need more than words right now. We are a community crying out for action. I am going to be calling today for a multi-agency approach with a clear strategic plan,” he said.

READ MORE

“[It should be] similar to the response that the north inner city received in recent years with the political will and a strong figurehead to address these issues. Because this cycle of bad events, strong condemnation and then simply move on needs to be broken.”

Mr de Róiste said Ballyfermot Garda station lacks resources to address problems fundamental issues in the area.

“Local gardaí go out to serve every day and to keep the community safe. Ballyfermot Garda station was downgraded about 15 years ago. We have skeleton response crews because frontline regular units are so depleted across the area,” he said.

“Regularly I hear stories of gardaí in an empty Garda station who are put in an impossible situation. We hear numbers along the lines of community teams that should have about 11 or 12 gardaí and sometimes have three or four gardaí.

“We hear numbers of a Garda station whereby there is literally someone just manning a desk. The lights are on in the station but there is literally nobody home. Calls come in and they have to be dealt with and guards who are on the desk need to send resources but very often they are not there.

“I spoke to a resident last week who said that if something is happening in the local area you are better off saying that there is a gun because you are guaranteed to get a response back. That is not good for gardaí and for a community that needs to feel safe. It is about looking for a way forward and for looking at a way to break that cycle that exists.”

Meanwhile, Former Garda Assistant Commissioner Pat Leahy told Newstalk Breakfast that body cameras are a requirement in a modern-day police service and far preferable than moving to arming members of An Garda Síochána with tasers.

“I would be absolutely in favour of progressing with this,” he said. I think the legislation will address the concerns involved. This argument has taken place across the world before it has landed in Ireland. It hasn’t come down on one side or the other definitively but there is good feedback on both sides.

“Both the public and police feel that it would protect them from each other in most jurisdictions. It is not a panacea. It is just another tool in the box.

“The gardaí certainly need to be protected in some way because the rules seem to have broken down in some areas and about two and a half thousand guards have been injured on duty over the last 10 years. That is just the tip of the iceberg. The majority of guards don’t report it because they see it as being part of parcel of the job they do.”

The executive director of the Irish Council for Civil Liberties Liam Herrick also spoke to the show. He condemned the attack in Ballyfermot. However, on a wider level he said that we operate “with the myth that Ireland has an unarmed police force” when between “20 and 30 per cent of members of An Garda Síochána are carrying firearms.”

Mr Herrick said that we need to have a discussion to ensure that gardaí have the necessary equipment to allow them to do their job but “if they are using force there needs to be proper regulation of it.”

He added: “If body cameras delivered benefits in terms of either protecting the guards and if they also reduced the inappropriate use of force by guards we would be for them. But unless you can prove that is the case what you are doing here is adding an additional level of surveillance so surveillance brings risks that private actions would be shared inappropriately and so on. You need to meet a threshold here.”

LATEST STORIES