Sir, - I wish to comment on some of the points raised by Sean Kilfeather in his article on the development of Croke Park (September 7th). Firstly, it's interesting to note that somebody out there regards the New Stand as the most beautiful building in Dublin. Have they never seen the Custom House, or any of the other gems of the city?
Secondly, Croke Park is an inappropriate location for a modern stadium. Most people travel to matches by car nowadays, and access to the vicinity of the ground is poor because the park is close to the city centre.
Parking is difficult, and vandalism of cars while matches are in progress seems to be a perennial problem. The pitch is quite cramped, and expansion of the stadium is not possible because of the canal and the railway. Not to mention the size of the New Stand relative to the surrounding houses and flats!
Thirdly, the difficulties of future construction - the "bits and pieces development" noted by Sean Kilfeather - would not have occurred if the GAA had opted for a green field site properly served by road and rail transport: a site to the west of Dublin, for example. Croke Park could be used during construction of the new stadium, and it would suffice in the future for all but the biggest occasions. For the rest of the year, the new stadium could be used for - dare I say it - other events and sports.
Heavens! A national stadium that would provide finance for the GAA! The popularity of the hurling championship in recent years has shown that, with correct marketing, the GAA need not be paranoid about other sports. Of course, it's too late now: the modernised Croke Park will be a triumph of sentimentality over logic.
Finally, hasn't enough government money been spent on the New Stand? There are innumerable causes which are more worthy. - Yours, etc.,
Clancy Strand,
Limerick