Middlesbrough's Stg£7million damages claim over Christian Ziege's controversial move to Liverpool was thrown out by a High Court judge today.
The Anfield club were being sued after being fined Stg£20,000 and the player Stg£10,000 by a Premier League inquiry which found there had been breaches of the league's rules prohibiting poaching of in-contract players.
Mr Justice Astill said today that Boro's action was based on "speculation" and had no realistic prospect of success.
David Phillips QC, representing Middlesbrough, had told the judge that Liverpool had exploited confidential knowledge of Ziege's contract with Middlesbrough which allowed transfer negotiations to go ahead if a minimum figure of Stg£5.5million was offered.
He said Ziege was worth Stg£7.5million, the sum offered by Rangers and Chelsea in August 2000.
If Liverpool had not made the approaches, Ziege would have stayed with Middlesbrough where he was happy and successful, said Phillips.
The Teesside club had lost more money because his transfer fee would have been enhanced had he stayed with Middlesbrough and the club would have been more successful in the League if he had been present.
Mr Justice Astill said Ziege, now at Tottenham, had no market value as a player because Middlesbrough had agreed to allowing him the Stg£5.5million clause in his contract.
"For footballing reasons he wanted to go to Liverpool and would go nowhere else for any other offer," said the judge.
Mr Justice Astill said Middlesbrough could never expect damages to be awarded by a court on the supposition that the club would have ended higher in the League if the player had stayed.
PA